When Marla (Laney Smith) receives a call that her Aunt Helen (Laura Durant) is ill and cannot tend to her mail store, Marla decides to take a break from her redundant city life and head to the small town of North Lake to help her Aunt Helen.
There, she meets Jesse Collins (Michael Jason Allen). After dating for a while, Marla begins to recognize Jesse's playboy reputation. Coupled with the interference of vindictive mean girl Cora (Joanna Ke), whom is an ex-girlfriend of Jesse's, Marla puts a permanent hold on things.

Jesse then tries to convince Marla that she's wrong about him and he only has good intentions towards her, so he throws out a desperate plea by giving her references of his ex-girlfriends to try and clear his name. Marla now finds herself playing detective to find out "the real" Jesse.
It is this unique plea that takes the story into a twist of emotional ups & downs... and a second guessing of intentions by all involved.
After all is done, this town with "no strangers" will be changed forever.